Owner request: test the popular “buy a long-dated deep-in-the-money call, sell short-dated calls against
it” income structure. We built it properly — rolling long LEAPS, monthly short calls managed by the
standard rules, realistic costs — on a basket of index and mega-cap names over 3 years.
Result: worst strategy on every measure tested
PMCC: +3.6%/yr with a -86.7% max drawdown, and negative out-of-sample — versus +34%/yr for a
classic covered call on the same names and +42%/yr for plain buy-and-hold. On the fastest-moving names the
structure went to approximately zero.
Why it fails structurally
The marketing says “covered call at a discount.” The math says ~4–5x leverage: your capital base
is the small LEAP premium, so every move in the stock is amplified — while your upside is capped by the
short call. Rips get run over by the cap; dips hit the levered base. You keep the downside amplification and
sell the upside that would pay for it. It only “works” in flat, low-volatility grinds — the one regime
where you barely needed a position at all.
Verdict: rejected, permanently. A good example of why we test structures, not stories: the story
sounds like income, the structure is levered short-gamma.