The owner asked the question every bull market asks: the diversifier sleeve and the oversold-dip overlay
earn less than the core — what would happen if we removed them? We rebuilt the full composite
all four ways:
| Variant | 7y CAGR | 7y maxDD | 7y Sharpe | 5y CAGR | 5y maxDD | 5y Sharpe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| As built | 30.8% | -14.8% | 1.70 | 25.8% | -11.5% | 1.47 |
| No dip overlay | 29.8% | -14.5% | 1.67 | 25.2% | -11.7% | 1.44 |
| No diversifier sleeve | 32.3% | -15.3% | 1.69 | 26.5% | -13.0% | 1.45 |
| Neither | 31.5% | -15.2% | 1.66 | 26.0% | -13.3% | 1.43 |
Dropping the diversifier sleeve buys about +1.5%/yr — at a deeper drawdown and a lower Sharpe
on both windows, and a worse 2022 (-6.5% as built vs -8.1% without). The dip overlay adds roughly
0.6–1.0%/yr nearly free, with drawdown flat-to-better. Separately, a per-bucket study confirmed the
diversifier sleeve’s best years land in the rest of the book’s worst years — which is the whole job.
Verdict: both stay. The fund’s standing preference is smooth equity over maximum CAGR; this test
priced that preference at about 1.5 points per year, and we paid it on purpose.